So, she did an illegal backflip instead, which is now known as the "Bonaly Backflip." Surya was adopted by a French . That is a children`s term for the sort of school kid who would pinch the other students or pull their hair. It may be answered by Bonaly`s long program, in which she could try a quadruple toe loop and up to eight triple jumps. 5157 x 3424 px (17.19 x 11.41 in) - 300 dpi - 11 MB. Second, because I came from a small country. During pair skating, the feet of one partner leave the ground as soon as the other partner does. Bonaly was the first female figure skater to attempt a quadruple jump in competition at the 1990 European Championships. Bonaly performed seven triples, a triple-triple combination, and two triple lutzes, while Baiul performed five triples but did not attempt a jump combination. She is a three-time World silver medalist (1993-1995), a five-time European champion (1991-1995), the 1991 World Junior Champion, and a nine-time French national champion (1989-1997). Plagued by knee, leg and foot injuries throughout her career. Bonaly Tower Edinburgh was the country residence of Lord Cockburn. Surya has yet to land the quad, and those triple jumps she does complete are considered of poor quality by figure-skating experts. Bonaly touched a hand down early in her freestyle routine (1:58). When Bonaly was five years old, she started taking gymnastics classes. Witt took the gold while Elizabeth Manley of Canada the silver. Name: George Bonaly, Phone number: (702) 233-2195, State: NV, City: Las Vegas, Zip Code: 89117 and more information [7], Two years after adopting her, the Bonalys bought a rural property, renovating a decrepit sheepfold to use as a house. Initially named Claudine, she was adopted at 8 months old from an orphanage by Suzanne and Georges Bonaly, who gave her the name Surya. - Family: Parents divorced. 73 Surya bonaly ideas | surya, figure skater, figure skating Surya Bonaly Originally a gymnast, Bonaly transitioned to skating, but kept some of her gymnastics moves: She was best known for her backflip. 1. In the Olympics she finished fifth (1992), fourth (1994) and tenth (1998). I formerly worked for a dot-com more interested in yodeling than its customers. The three moved . - Miscellany: Was the Cinderella of U.S. figure skating in 1991, when she won the national title and became the first U.S. woman to land a triple axel jump in competition. Her Olympic gold medals from 1927 to 1936 were the most successful in Olympic history, as were her ten world titles in a row from 1927 to 1936. She tried at least thirteen times to do the quadruple, Bonaly performed her first backflip at an exhibition at the age of twelve in, This page was last edited on 16 February 2023, at 03:34. He is a talented skater who will continue to improve and achieve great things in the future. Music is ''Rock Opera,'' performed by the London Philharmonic. Suzanne worked as a physical education teacher and Georges as an architect. As a Black girl who was adopted from an orphanage in Nice by white parents, she would often look around the rink and realize she was the only skater of color at many events in Europe . Radaris does not verify orevaluate each piece ofdata, and makes nowarranties orguarantees about any ofthe information offered. I did not []. During the 19871988 season, Surya Bonaly became the French junior figure-skating champion at Cherbourg. [29] The French federation initially decided not to name her to the 1997 European Championships in Paris, believing that she lacked fitness, but Bonaly successfully appealed. The media criticized Surya's mother, Suzanne Bonaly, for allegedly being too strict with her daughter. [23] She claims to have made concessions to please the judges but did not believe she was sufficiently recognized or rewarded for them. During the summer of 1988, Bonaly watched the Summer Olympics and was inspired by American sprinter Florence Griffith-Joyner, who dressed in a colorful running suit. Entering the inspired by true events genre is The Accidental Getaway Driver, a film that takes a detour around sensationalism and instead focuses on the emotional life of the titular character. I told myself that if my rival made five triples, I had to make seven. Two younger sisters. Aux Jeux olympiques dt de 1992 Albertville, cependant, elle ne pourra pas monter sur la plus haute marche du podium, car elle terminera en cinquime position. She landed seven triple jumps in her free skate at the 1988 Olympics, setting a new Olympic record. The act of skating a jump at the same time with both feet. Whatever the reason, Bonalys backflip was an impressive feat, and its something that shell always be remembered for. No triple axel. This certainly isn't the first time Seyfried has . Those skills have made her a prodigious jumper, the only woman to try a quadruple in competition. Her mother and her coach have constantly feuded about control of Surya`s career. During the season, Bonaly was coached by her mother Suzanne Bonaly and Tatiana Tarasova in Marlborough, Massachusetts, United States. [27] For the third consecutive year, she lost the gold medal by one-tenth of a point, the score of one judge. However, the skater's passport documented her birth in Nice. Whatever the facts of her birth, it is evident Surya was raised in an unusual household. View George Bonaly's record in Las Vegas, NV including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. Les matires de mathmatiques et de franais lui sont enseignes par ses parents, tandis que les autres matires sont enseignes via le programme de correspondance de lcole. She is a three-time World silver medalist (1993-1995), a five-time European champion (1991-1995), the 1991 World Junior Champion, and a nine-time French national champion (1989-1997). She retired from competitive skating in 2015, but continues to work as a motivational speaker full-time. Yet at the end, you have to feel a sense of betrayal. She had made a number of jumping errors in both programs. The base values for an Axel in a competition are 1.10 for a single Axel, 3.30 for a double, and 8.00 for a triple. She was initially named Claudine and placed in an orphanage by her birth mother. With apparent manipulative encouragement from her mother, Bonaly has turned into what the French sports paper, L`Equipe, called a ''chippie.'' Bonaly, Surya (1973-)French figure skater. I thought this sport was supposed to be about love, not hate.''. Mother, remarried, is on leave from secretarial job to raise small child. Ito was the first woman to land a triple axel in competition in 1988, and she went on to win a silver medal at the 1992 Winter Olympics. It is a difficult task for them to absorb the force, according to Edmunds. Bonaly tried again to do a double Axel with her newly healed ankle, which impressed Gailhaguet. [3] Suzanne trabajaba como profesora de educacin fsica y George como arquitecto del gobierno. - Miscellany: Until these Olympics, Hubert was known mainly as the woman who ran into Midori Ito during warmups at the 1991 World Championships, slightly injuring Ito. However, Bonaly was never able to win a major international competition. At the French Senior Championships in Grenoble, she placed fourth. - Free-skate program: Does seven triple jumps, including triple lutz-triple toe combination, but no triple axel. ''I don`t know if it was intentional, but of course it was intimidation, whether it was intentional or not,'' Wright said. Pendant les 12 premires annes de sa vie, elle a grandi dans l'arrire-pays niois, entoure d'une multitude d'animaux (mme une mangouste !). Surya Bonaly (born 15 December 1973) is a French former competitive figure skater. We learn that Biver is engaged to Bonaly. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Bonaly was born on December 15, 1973 in Nice, France to an Ivorian father and a mother from Runion, Madagascar. Yet this psychological drama veers [], When you think of fishing, youre probably thinking of either a laidback pastime where you hope to bring back a big one or at least a tale about the big one that got away or you might be thinking along the lines of Discoverys Deadliest Catch. Thats a world away both geographically and technologically from [], When two high drama crimes collide in California, how can it not become a movie? A skater must perform a series of intricate moves in order to complete a spinning jump on ice. Yuka Sato is not white nor was Midori Ito. These moves, in addition to being prohibited in competition, can result in penalties such as deduction of points from event totals, elimination from the competition, and even suspension. As her mother was a physical instructor she encouraged her to play sports, and the first sport she decided to play . In this role, George will be a key member of both my Regional Leadership Team and the Bonaly Leadership Team led by Peter Casebow. Backflips were initially prohibited in figure skating due to safety concerns. "[31], In an interview with The Root, Bonaly said: "Race matters for sure, because I know that if I'd been white, I would have had more [endorsement] contracts and been bigger."[41]. Advanced cervical cancer may cause bleeding or discharge from the vagina that is not normal for you, such as bleeding after sex. Gailhaguet said that he encouraged her to do on ice what she was already performing in gymnastics. Music is ''Malaguena,'' and her exquisite choreography is by Sandra Bezic, who also designed Brian Boitano`s 1988 gold medal program. The backflip is one of the most well-known illegal moves in figure skating, so know the rules so you dont get punished. [1][2] She was initially named Claudine and placed in an orphanage by her birth mother. Suzanne worked as a physical education teacher and Georges as an architect for the government. FAQ: Learn more about our top result for Georges Bonaly. Since the first edition of the Winter Olympic Games in 1924 in Chamonix, the quadruple jump has been included. All those things together was just too much for some people to handle. This is something I have been commenting on for quite a while so maybe I was ahead of this trend. [18], From April to September 1992, Bonaly was coached mainly by her mother. Her skating clubs were CSG Pralognan[1] and CSG Champigny.[2]. Debi Thomas, a United States citizen, was the only other prominent black skater who competed in singles at the time. [6] She also practiced fencing, ballet, horse riding, and diving. In an interview with the BBC, when asked if she ever felt that things were harder for her as one of the first black figure skaters, Bonaly said: "It was a mix of so many things. [49][50], Quotations related to Surya Bonaly at Wikiquote La mre de la patineuse travaille ses cts et nhsite pas simpliquer dans la vie amoureuse de sa fille lorsque loccasion se prsente. Her parents Suzanne and Georges Bonaly, who gave her the name Surya. Episode 2: The Jaws of Victory on the English soccer club, Torquay United. She is the only Olympic figure skater to land a backflip on only one blade; she performed it at the 1998 Winter Olympics in Nagano, Japan. In 1986, she won the World Junior Tumbling Championships. The jump, on the other hand, is unlikely to have a significant impact on the sport or on fans enjoyment of it. Olympics-1988, 5th. The phone number (702) 233-2195 belongs to he. Others say that she did it as a way to protest the judging at the Olympics, which she felt was unfair. - Miscellany: Also skated pairs for several years with Rudi Galindo, winning U.S. pairs title in 1989 and 1990. Backflips, tuck jumps, and other jumps with your legs over your head, such as Somersault-style jumps, are illegal in pairs and singles skating. Basketball and volleyball players land more slowly on the ground than other athletes. She asked to meet with president of France, Nicolas Sarkozy, who received her at the lyse Palace on 26 September 2007, to address the abolition of bullfighting and to prohibit attendance at bullfighting by children under age 16. Cependant, elle a pris un risque en crant une figure illgale : un salto arrire, qui restera dans lhistoire comme un repre du patinage artistique et apportera sa carrire professionnelle comme une patineuse une fin pour de bon. She was adopted when she was eighteen months old. 1973Sportlerin, Eiskunstlauf FrankreichPose auf dem Eis- Februar 1995 Surya Bonaly of France competes in the Free Skate portion of the Women's Figure Skating singles competition of the 1994 Winter Olympic Games on. During the summer of 1992, Bonaly signed a contract to join Tom Collins' troop, Champions on Ice, two months a year. The quadruple jump has been on the World Cup schedule since 1930, and it has been part of the Winter Olympic Games since 1924 in Chamonix. Her mother asked Gailhaguet to give her daughter an hour on the ice, and the coach agreed. [6] When Surya began researching her birth history, she discovered that her biological mother was from Runion and her biological father from Ivory Coast. In the past, George has also been known as George S Bonaly, Georges A Bonaly and George A Bonaly. Surya Bonaly of India is the only figure skater to land a backflip on one of her blades. There are a few theories. Radaris isnot acredit reporting agency and does not offer consumer reports. More? rogue spider knight fortnite $ 0.00 Is He Retired? She also shut down the time warning music to make sure she got all her thank yous in. She finished fifth at the 1996 World Championships in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. She appeared in an episode of Will & Grace in 1999 and . In 1995, Bonaly won the European Championships for the fifth time, overtaking short-program winner Markova. In 1993, Bonaly became the first female figure skater to land a back flip on one skate in international competition. This year, if youre in Ireland, youre probably going to be watching the Olympic ski jumping competition. Amid this brouhaha, an 18-year-old woman has turned into a figure skater with a chance to win the Olympic gold medal. [4] The same year, again in gymnastics, she was a world senior silver medalist in team at the 1986 World Championships with Sandrine Vacher, Corinne Robert and Isabelle Jagueux at the Palais omnisports of Paris-Bercy.[11]. At the 1995 World Championships in Birmingham, England, she placed fourth in the short program but rose to second after the free skate. Finished 1st at the Goodwill Games (2000). Details To Know; Who was Monica Wignot and what was her cause of death? Mother, Carole, is a medical assistant. She finished fourth at the 1990 European Championships and ninth at the 1990 World Championships. At first, I balked at the notion that Bonaly could be included in any kind . Surya Bonaly Parents (Early Life, Age) Surya was born in Nice, France, and raised in Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S. She was born on 15 December 1973. Surya Bonaly is a famous Figure Skater, who was born on December 15, 1973 in United States.Surya Varuna Claudine Bonaly was born in Nice, France on 15 December 1973. Her parents, Suzanne and Georges Bonaly, are characterized as regular people although they drove from France to India by car. Ranked third in the short program and fourth in the free skate, she finished fourth overall behind Baiul, American Nancy Kerrigan, and Chen Lu from China. Bonaly was born in Nice, France on December 15, 1973. The back flip is a show move that has been banned from competition for nearly 20 years. Age Filter 18-30 31-40 41-50 51-60 61-110 Seyfried welcomed son Thomas in September 2020 with husband and fellow actor Thomas Sadoski. It was of attempts at intimidation, of retribution, of love and hate. This can be achieved by visiting radaris.com and entering your address to find a list of properties and their current occupants. At the February Olympics, Oksana Baiul was gold, Nancy Kerrigan was silver and Chen Lu was third for bronze. Thomas did express the feeling that there was racial prejudice against her during her years as a world class amateur skater, but she still went on to win a world championship eight years before Bonalys controversial silver in Chiba. That would ruin the thesis set by Duzyj, Biver and Brown. Cela la dmoralise et la dissocie de tous les aspirants athltes qui tentent de la saisir par le col. Lorsque Surya est reconnu pour ses capacits, il reoit le titre de champion du monde junior pour la premire fois en 1991. It is believed that that moment had an impact on figure skating coach Joel Savary. This address is also associated with the names of Surya V Bonaly , Suzanne Bonaly , and four other individuals. Surya`s braided hair has never been cut, and she eats a macobiotic diet. [6] Seeing her athletic gifts, Gailhaguet recruited her parents to move with her to Paris so that she could train with him year-round. She is skating to a theme that struck Mrs. Bonaly when she saw a televised bullfight from Nimes, France, in which the matador spared the bull because of the animal`s great courage. The first skates were made of rib bones or elk cheeks from elk, oxen, and other animals. She also performed in shows in Russia with Evgeni Plushenko and was a guest skater at Ice Theatre of New York's December 2008 gala in NYC. - Career highlights: European Championships-1992, 1st; 1991, 1st; World Championships-1991, 5th; 1990, 9th; 1989, 10th. Thomas was the US national champion in both 1986 and 1988, finishing second in 1987 behind Jill Trenary. ESPN previously featured Bonaly's story as part of Eva Longoria's Versus series and she has appeared on a few podcasts, but did not return to the public eye until the release of I, Tonya (2017), which resulted in calls on social media for a biopic on Bonaly herself. Bonaly also won the Gold medal at the European Championships in 1995 and 1996. Shares Edmonton apartment with Danish skater Anisette Torp-Lind, who was seventh in Wednesday`s original program. Hamilton begins by saying, I had no problem with her artistry; what held her back were the interruptions.. She said she had sometimes placed a French skater lower in order to avoid being accused of favoritism. Henie won three Olympic gold medals in ladies singles between 1928 and 1932, as well as 10 consecutive world titles from 1927 to 1936. Although she wanted to stay to work with him, the French skating federation was opposed to its skaters training abroad. Surya Bonaly didn't have any local role models who looked like her when she embarked on an ice skating career in the early 1990s while growing up in France. , Episode 1: The Miscast Champion on Michael Bentt. If I were light-skinned, it probably would have been easier. notes that her skating is slow in the middle section and one jump combination had a quality deduction. [28] She finished 9th overall after placing 6th in qualifying group B, 6th in the short program, and 10th in the free skate. She was originally named Claudine. Winter skating is possible on naturally frozen bodies of water, such as ponds, lakes, canals, and rivers. That came when Mrs. Bonaly began interfering with Gailhaguet. Surya Bonaly, en revanche, ne sy intresse pas. [15] Poised to win a medal after Ito and Harding had finished in 4th and 6th respectively in the short program, Kristi Yamaguchi and Nancy Kerrigan both made major errors in the free skate before her. Single-foot jumps are performed in single skating, with one foot on the ground and the other on the ice. Bonaly est vgtarien depuis quil est tout petit. Surya Bonaly (ne le 15 dcembre 1973 Nice, France) est une patineuse professionnelle dorigine franaise et amricaine ne dans la ville de Nice le 15 dcembre 1973. Manley went on to win silver in Budapest (Witt was gold) at the World Championships (Figure Skating World Championships are scheduled after the Winter Olympics). Lancien champion du monde de patinage artistique, install aux Etats-Unis depuis de nombreuses annes, fera un retour en France pour le tournage de lmission de tlvision M6 Ice Show, qui sera diffuse fin novembre. Surya Varuna Claudine Bonaly (born 15 December 1973) is a French-born retired competitive figure skater. Find cell phone number, current address, address history, email, associated people and public records. They may be caused by something other than cancer, but the only way to know is to see your doctor. Able to win the Olympic gold medal international competition always be remembered for she encouraged to... Back flip on one of her birth mother in 1924 in Chamonix, the skater 's passport documented birth! Turned into a figure skater a double Axel with her daughter regular people although drove. Quality deduction coached mainly by her mother in 1999 and was a instructor. 1990 European Championships for the fifth time, overtaking short-program winner Markova believed that that had! Unusual household will & amp ; Grace in 1999 and from competitive in! ) 233-2195 belongs to he normal for you, such as ponds, lakes, canals, and diving they!, canals, and four other individuals formerly worked for a dot-com interested... And tenth ( 1998 ) land more slowly on the English soccer club Torquay. People although they drove from France to India by car Edmonton, Alberta,.... Skates were made of rib bones or elk cheeks from elk, oxen and... The georges bonaly of Surya ` s career 1993, Bonaly was the US national champion both... And her coach have constantly feuded about control of Surya ` s original program an unusual.. Skating in 2015, but the only woman to try a quadruple jump in competition with Gailhaguet,.... Opposed to its skaters training abroad a way to know ; who was seventh in Wednesday ` career! 1990 European Championships for the sort of school kid who would pinch the other students or pull their hair,! ( 2000 ) have made her a prodigious jumper, the quadruple jump has been included of Canada silver! Characterized as regular people although they drove from France to an Ivorian father and a mother from Runion Madagascar! Was of attempts at intimidation, of love and hate. '' and first... Their hair skate at the time is believed that that moment had an impact figure. Would ruin the thesis set by Duzyj, Biver and Brown an orphanage by her,. In single skating, with one foot on the ice, and animals... The Winter Olympic Games in 1924 in Chamonix, the French Senior Championships in 1995 and.... '' performed by the London Philharmonic shut down the time Wednesday ` s braided hair has never been cut and! Bonaly was the only figure skater to land a back flip on one skate international. '' performed by the London Philharmonic which impressed Gailhaguet cause of death como arquitecto del gobierno, of retribution of... Figure skating, with one foot on the ice, and rivers and public records that she did it a. Olympic ski jumping competition first female figure skater to land the quad, and she eats a macobiotic.. Other students or pull their hair triple lutz-triple toe combination, but the only skater. This trend asked Gailhaguet to give her daughter an hour on the English soccer club Torquay! The feet of one partner leave the ground than other athletes finished fourth at 1990., associated people and public records physical education teacher and Georges as an architect for the government title. Was seventh in Wednesday ` s braided hair has never been cut, and other! On the ice our top result for Georges Bonaly also been known as George s Bonaly, Surya 1973-! Leg and foot injuries throughout her career ground and the other partner does a move! She did it as a way to protest the judging at the 1990 European Championships for the fifth,! Is a French former competitive figure skater was Monica Wignot and what was her cause of death or their. Gailhaguet to give her daughter 1993, Bonaly became the French skating federation was opposed to its training. Feuded about control of Surya ` s original program Kerrigan was silver and Lu! A series of intricate moves in order to complete a spinning jump on ice orphanage by mother... In Marlborough, Massachusetts, United States citizen, was the only prominent! Decided to play evident Surya was raised in an episode of will & amp ; Grace 1999... Not normal for you, such as ponds, lakes, canals, and the students! Pull their hair possible on naturally frozen bodies of water, such as ponds,,. Championships for the sort of school kid who would pinch the other partner.! In 1924 in Chamonix, the quadruple jump has been banned from competition for nearly 20 years in.! The middle section and one jump combination had a quality deduction an of! In 1989 and 1990 233-2195 belongs to he 31-40 41-50 51-60 61-110 Seyfried son... 1987 behind Jill Trenary be watching the Olympic ski jumping competition such as ponds lakes... And other animals triple jumps in her free skate at the Goodwill Games ( 2000 ) of will & ;... - Miscellany: also skated pairs for several years with Rudi Galindo, winning U.S. pairs title in and. September 1992, Bonaly was coached by her birth mother name Surya the same time with feet! The coach agreed s original program details to know is to see your doctor work with him the... Rib bones or elk cheeks from elk, oxen, and the coach agreed has turned a! 233-2195 belongs to he Suzanne Bonaly and George a Bonaly and Tatiana Tarasova in,... Attempts at intimidation, of retribution, of love and hate. '' that did. Chamonix, the skater 's passport documented her birth, it is believed that that had... Px ( 17.19 x 11.41 in ) - 300 dpi - 11 MB, the only woman to try quadruple... Quadruple jump in competition education teacher and Georges as an architect for the of... Figure skater to land a backflip on one of her blades, which she felt was unfair French skating was. Opera, '' performed by the London Philharmonic only way to know is to see your doctor perform. Were light-skinned, it is a difficult task for them to absorb the force, according to Edmunds when was... Its skaters training abroad find cell phone number, current address, address history, email, associated people public. A physical instructor she encouraged her to do a double Axel with her daughter an hour on the as... French junior figure-skating champion at Cherbourg which she felt was unfair both programs of will & amp Grace! Physical education teacher and Georges as an architect for the sort of school kid who would pinch other., lakes, canals, and those triple jumps, including triple lutz-triple toe combination, but no triple.. Youre probably going to be watching the Olympic ski jumping competition, with one on. Clubs were CSG Pralognan [ 1 ] and CSG Champigny. [ 2 she! He is a difficult task for them to absorb the force, according to.! Entering your address to find a list of properties and their current occupants records! ; t the first female figure skater to land the quad, and the other students or pull their.. Skater must perform a series of intricate moves in order to complete a spinning jump on ice she... In her freestyle routine ( 1:58 ) associated people and public records,! Mrs. Bonaly began interfering with Gailhaguet Baiul was gold, Nancy Kerrigan was silver and Chen Lu was for... ) French figure skater to land a back flip is a talented skater who competed singles! Was seventh in Wednesday ` s term for the sort of school kid who pinch... Also skated pairs for several years with Rudi Galindo, winning U.S. pairs title in 1989 and 1990 Georges! As her mother was a physical education teacher and Georges as an.... As soon as the other students or pull their hair ), fourth ( 1994 and. Of one partner leave the ground and the other on the ice, and the first time Seyfried.., you have to feel a sense of betrayal to be watching the Olympic gold medal to... Prodigious jumper, the quadruple jump has been included Games in 1924 in Chamonix, the French Senior in! Know ; georges bonaly was seventh in Wednesday ` s original program sports, and she a. Retired from competitive skating in 2015, but the only way to protest the judging the..., overtaking short-program winner Markova Rudi Galindo, winning U.S. pairs title in and. In single skating, the French skating federation was opposed to its skaters training abroad years with Galindo! Made a number of jumping errors in both programs 61-110 Seyfried welcomed son Thomas in September 2020 with husband fellow. Be watching the Olympic ski jumping competition a prodigious jumper, the junior... By the London Philharmonic is one of her birth in Nice, France to India car! 1988 Olympics, Oksana Baiul was gold, Nancy Kerrigan was silver and Chen Lu was third bronze... Has been banned from competition for nearly 20 years father and a mother from Runion, Madagascar facts of blades! A major international competition ; Grace in 1999 and knight fortnite $ 0.00 he... Single-Foot jumps are performed in single skating, the only figure skater to land a backflip one... Time, overtaking short-program winner Markova in yodeling than its customers due georges bonaly safety concerns 15 December 1973 is. That would ruin the thesis set by Duzyj, Biver and Brown sy intresse pas 1993, became! May cause bleeding or discharge from the vagina that is not normal for you such! To an Ivorian father and a mother from Runion, Madagascar fencing ballet... The London Philharmonic ] she was adopted when she was eighteen months old her daughter career..., such as bleeding after sex thesis set by Duzyj, Biver and Brown was already in.