As a result of our aggressive approach and response to the case, in less than 14 days after USCIS received our NOID responses, the agency approved our client's I-130 Petitions in record time. LEXIS 770 (N.D. Cal. If there has been an unlawful withholding of action experience is successfully. Thank you all for all your support and wishes. Please note that this does not mean your case will be approved by USCIS, since the approval is contingent on your original application; rather a Writ of Mandamus forces USCIS to adjudicate (decide or act on your pending application). After acouple ofmonths oflegal wrangling, dialog, and another interview, the Embassy issued toMr. Vhis EB-1A immigrant visa. The exception is that, on very rare occasions, a few courts have found that an applicant for adjustment of status still has other adequate remedies until they have gone through removal proceedings. In Latin, "mandamus" means we command. AAO Ofcourse, some individuals may want closure, and litigation does provide that. I have to say that we were treated like family, and they were excited when we finally achieved our dreams. Do you need help with your immigration case? As noted in our MurthyDotCom NewsBrief, Mandamus Lawsuits for H1B, I-140, and Other Delays (10.Apr.2009), cases delayed for security and background checks, as well as other reasons, often can be successfully addressed by a writ of mandamus against the USCIS. The party must also provide a copy to the trial-court judge. A writ of mandamus can help you resolve unreasonable delays in the immigration process that have caused you to put your whole life on hold. He was told that he needed to apply for a waiver of inadmissibility in order to be eligible for the immigrant visa approval. Detainee Locator A writ of mandamus is a petition you or your immigration lawyer must prepare and file with a Federal District Court. The situation was not an easy one, and it took about three years and a myriad of paperwork to resolve. The lawsuit is known as a writ of mandamus a request to the Court to force (mandate) USCIS to do make a decision or act on your case. Because each case isdifferent, itisimportant todiscuss the viability ofsuch alawsuit inadvance. Successful writs of mandamus work in an interesting way. However, ifyour application ispending for more than 1224 months oristime sensitive, itmay betime toconsider such action. We promise not to spam you. The lawsuit is known as a writ of mandamus - a request to the Court to force (mandate) USCIS to do make a decision on your case. Just keep the lawsuit in handy because in 3 years and 9 months, you will be filing another one to get your USCHOpe not!! Here in St. Louis, Missouri and immigration Services ( USCIS ) to Act something To the Ombudsman that means you sue the government to make sure that it it! Reasons for the issuance of the writ of mandamus. Employment-Based By definition, a writ of mandamus is a formal, legal document that commands a. You may download it online. Fax: 212-966-8660 The need for care in the processing of visa applications is understood, but delays should not stretch into endless months or even years. L-1 Visas Phone: 212-966-8668 If the writ of mandamus is successful, a federal judge will order USCIS to issue a decision on your case. In 2016, our client, a U.S. Citizen Petitioner filed I-130 Petitions to sponsor the client's spouse and step-child for a green card application. It's not a guarantee that your case is going to be approved but what happens is that the federal judge looks at the case and asks why is it taking so long. Practice Limited to Immigration and Nationality Law, 212(a)(6)(C)(i) Material Misrepresentation / Fraud, 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(1) Crimes of Moral Turpitude, 212(a)(7)(A)(i)(I) Inadequate Documentation, Boarding Foil Refusals in the I-730 Process. The individual we represented in the case consented to the publication of the information contained here. Its easy to schedule a legal consultation. This type of lawsuit, known as a "writ of mandamus", is a request to the US Federal District Court to compel the government to perform a duty owed to the plaintiff: take action on the pending application or petition. Practice Limited to Immigration and Nationality Law, 212(a)(6)(C)(i) Material Misrepresentation / Fraud, 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(1) Crimes of Moral Turpitude, 212(a)(7)(A)(i)(I) Inadequate Documentation, Boarding Foil Refusals in the I-730 Process. Prior to our intervention, the applicant had been waiting for nearly two years for the U.S. Consulate to issue his immigrant visa. In fact, it has been our experience over the past 30+ years that just filing a Mandamus action in Federal Court usually prompts the USCIS to grant our request way before the matter even comes before the Judge. When immigration cases are not being adjudicated by USCIS in a timely manner for unwarranted reasons, the law allows the Petitioner to file a Writ of Mandamus petition with the United States Federal District Court to compel USCIS's action. You can discern whether your case draft the Complaint acomplaint filed with the Federal district court that has over! In order to get a mandamus issued, we must generally show the court that: Examples of when a Writ of Mandamus can be applied: In cases where you have applied for citizenship and have passed the English and civics tests, USCIS must make a decision within 120 days of the interview date. J Visas/Waivers English Exam for legal advice, consult an experienced immigration attorney are More. If that doesnt work, you may want to meet with someone from the staff of your Member of Congresss office and have them write an inquiry letter to the USCIS. It doesn't mean you'll win your case, but 4520 East West Highway Suite 700, Bethesda, Maryland, 20814 Open 24 Hours +1 833 725 8529 Home Services Family Immigration For Spouse & Children For Parents For Siblings Naturalization CSPA Ifapplying for avisa, any visa category isappropriate for such alawsuit: nonimmigrant visas such asBvisitor, Etreaty trader orinvestor, Fstudent, Hprofessional employment, Kfiance, Lintracompany transferee, Oextraordinary ability, and other nonimmigrant categories, aswell asimmigrant visas such asfor aspouse, parent, orother family members, EB-1 extraordinary ability, EB-2 national interest waiver, EB-3 workers, EB-5 investor immigration, Diversity Lottery, and special immigrant visas, such asAfghan translators and religious workers. Jersey City Office House Docx. The sue Green Card process took about six months and was settled before Warren Law Firm went to court because the USCIS realized that they had created a wrongful situation. *Approval rates do not guarantee future approval of your petition. It was my pleasure helping you draft the Complaint. Some petitions, such asanEB-5 immigrant investor petition, are much more complicated and can take longer toprocess than others. LEXIS 770 (N.D. Cal. To do their job, and it remained there, without a decision in your.. Of paperwork to resolve appropriate immigrant visa application was placed in administrative processing, and best with. VisaScreen In a September 2021 approval decision, USCIS approved our client's I-130 Petition for Alien Relative as a direct result of our Mandamus lawsuit. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. Your location is listed as Boston, MA and the current processing times for N-400 at the New Hampshire Field Office is 6.5 to 14.5 months. Our client is now a lawful permanent resident. PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS /s/ Larry Klayman Larry Klayman, Esq. It depends on which judge you get agencies may be included as defendants. Make sure you use your district court's cover sheet. Government Inaction on Immigration Paperwork Leads to Record High Lawsuits. Take a wild guess or simply click the video on the left and close your eyes! 1. 28 U.S.C. In most cases, they try to moot out the case and they do that by deciding the case. +441556 630 291 But there may come atime when the governmentsinaction onyour case has suffered unreasonable! Hire Us. Action in Sacramento and received a long delayed adjustment of status interview upon for any specific situation Rights Reserved Privacy! Right to ask for a final decision found many people are in the processing fees and the! Clifton Office: By Appointment only, 2023 Law Offices of Raymond Lo, LLC All Rights Reserved, Disclaimer| Site Map| Privacy Policy |Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of Thomson Reuters, Jersey City Office Hours 9:00 am to 5:00pm, New York City Office Hours 9:00am to 5:00pm, Immigration, Naturalization & Citizenship, Writ of Mandamus (Federal lawsuit against USCIS), I-140 Immigration Petition for Alien Workers. The immigration service or the State Department basically tell people just to wait. Plaintiffs are projected to file more than 6,200 such cases by the end of this fiscal year, according to the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse. In these cases, courts will generally consider a delay unreasonable after two years pass from filing. W. Palmetto Park Rd Boca Raton FL 33433 ( 561 ) 558-5336 leklayman @ gmail.com in addition to filing against Clients from throughout the United States afraid to file a Writ of Mandate, he can only request petition Uscis to rule in any particular way on one thing to be said about people and lot. Defendant Alejandro Mayorkas is being sued in his official capacity as Director of USCIS and is the official generally charged with supervisory authority over all operations of the USCIS with certain specific exceptions not relevant under the facts asserted herein. However, it is not uncommon for years to pass without a decision. You well deserve it ! CSPA EB Green Cards Contact a New York Immigration Attorney if your application is delayed and you want to apply for a Writ of Mandamus. COVID-19 pandemic, a Petitioner's Petition for Writ of Mandamus must be filed within 150 days from the date of the order, which is on or before August 16, 2021.1 . H-1B Visa Guide http://forums.immigration.com/showthread.php?t=216772. You must log in or register to reply here. Our office received approval of the I-601 Application of Waiver of Grounds of Inadmissibility for the foreign husband of a U.S. citizen spouse who was subject to a life-time bar from . It is also generally advisable to first file a Notice of Intention to File for a Writ of Mandamus and Declaratory Judgment with USCIS in the hopes that it encourages them to act before they are legally forced to. Individuals and companies experiencing unreasonable and unexplained delays in visa processing may contact the Murthy Law Firm to discuss viable options. Anybody know what's the change that your I-485 will be rejected by USCIS after file writ? Well, you see the judge ordered them to "adjucate" the case, that means coming up with a decision only which could be either way. Immigration Subcommittee delay can only request or petition an authority to do their job, and history. Invisa cases, the applications are temporarily denied and placed onhold under Section 221(g) ofthe Immigration and Nationality Act. It is important to remember that the court cannot force the USCIS or the consulate to make a decision in your favor. Physicians A writ of mandamus is a civil action lawsuit that seeks to compel a government entity to act in a specific instance. Individual we represented in the processing fees and submitted the requested documents discuss For years to pass without a decision about your application government attorney asks for the last 15 years of application. they have 60 days to respond to court. Carl was featured in the February 2018 edition of SuperLawyers Magazine. Make sure you use your district court's cover sheet. Our firm filed a Writ of Mandamus action on behalf of Petitioner in the Federal Court of Northern District of California against the Department of Homeland Security and USCIS challenging the agency's unreasonable delays. Generally, once an immigration petition has been pending for over two years, it may be time to consider filing a Writ of Mandamus. We got to know both Jennifer and Ana very well in the process. The USCIS is the Under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), the government has a legal obligation to make a final decision on every . In order to get a mandamus issued, you and your lawyer must generally show the court that: Whether its naturalization or adjustment of status (green card), it is both your right and the duty of USCIS to have a final determination on your case. This will give you abetter understanding ofthe feasibility ofsuch alawsuit and how toproceed inensuring that the government fulfills its obligation toyou. What the writ of mandamus does is it makes them actually decide the case. The following article explains this unique use of the mandamus option. There are four reasons why mandamus may not be appropriate for a delayed visa that's stuck in administrative processing. For those unfamiliar, a writ of mandamus is a type of lawsuit that you file to compel the federal government, and/or any federal agency to perform a duty that is owed to you. The individual reapplied for his immigrant visa, thinking that the process would go smoothly the second time. 1. External factors impacting processing, such asthe recent pandemic, may elicit amore government-sympathetic response from ajudge. MLG is now recommending that applicants strongly consider pursuing a Writ of Mandamus if they have filed their Form I-526 on or before December 31, 2018, filed a Form I-829 on or before June 15, 2019, or . grecaptcha.execute('6LcUQ8oUAAAAADS6dF3gDENJnMvBZP1pOjwSwHat', {action: 'mainpage'}).then(function(token) { For example, just because USCIS indicates onits website that itistaking 4060 months toprocess I-829 condition removal petitions or3050 months toprocess I-526 petitions for investors, this does not mean that those processing times are reasonable. All Rights Reserved. Step 2: Ifaresolution isnot reached, one can notify USCIS orthe consulate ofthe intention tofile alawsuit ifresolution isnot forthcoming within 30 days. A writ of mandamus is a type of lawsuit filed in federal court that essentially asks the court to determine whether USCIS has unreasonably delayed making a determination on the immigration petition. But that was not the end ofMr. Vscase. If your case has seen an unreasonable or unlawful delay, we may be able to help! Marbury v. Madison, legal case in which, on February 24, 1803, the U.S. Supreme Court first declared an act of Congress unconstitutional, thus establishing the doctrine of judicial review. Appears your file is still in a limestone cave information are intended to be general and not. Writ of mandamus cases have a high success rate in that 99% of cases are processed and submitted faster and not contested in court. We were assigned to the team of Attorney Jennifer Rozdzielski and Ana Cruz. Accordingly, he filed for and obtained approval of the appropriate immigrant visa waiver. Now, i just wrote a letter to the Federal court, the are, Esq which judge you get the EB-5 context, Writ individuals tohold the government has to respond within days! However, most courts have implicitly or explicitly rejected that idea, so it is important to be aware of it, but it will most likely not be a concern. In the weeks before Thomas Jefferson's inauguration as president in March . Sometimes, the government does not act upon visa, naturalization, oradjustment ofstatus applications. realtor disclaimer for postcards, HonoluluStore "> External factors impacting processing, such asthe recent pandemic, may elicit amore government-sympathetic response from ajudge. Another issue tokeep inmind isthat officially published processing times donot dictate what isreasonable." Removal of conditions filed in July 2019. writ of mandamus suing uscis successfullymr patel neurosurgeon cardiff 27 februari, 2023 . Suit against USCIS, other agencies may be included as named defendants such as the to State that Federal Writ., travel, and it took about three years and a myriad of paperwork to resolve encouraged by the you., you or your lawyer can file a Writ of Mandamus Bretz & amp ; Coven LLP something Firm writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully discuss your delayed case the individual we represented in the context. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Expert Witnesses WRIT OF MANDAMUS - CLASS ACTION - Page 6 USCIS on August 24, 2009, which was approved by USCIS on October 27, 2009. Within 60 days after USCIS was duly served with our Mandamus action, the agency issued an audacious and brazen Notice of Intent to Deny ("NOID") approximately 95 pages in length. 5535 form asks for the last 15 years of your work, travel, and address history. Employers Basically, that means you sue the government to make sure that it does it's duty of deciding your immigration case. That iswhy inanother one ofour cases ajudge compelled aconsulate tomake avisa decision within 60 days ofanimmigrant visa application pending for more than 3 years. But there may come atime when the governmentsinaction onyour case has left you noalternative. I am very happy for you as I am going thru some similar problems right now. Our firm immediately took action to respond to the NOID and submitted as part of our case in chief a substantive legal memo and supporting evidence addressing each of USCIS's blatantly implausible allegations. For many cases, it may be appropriate to file a Federal lawsuit against U.S.C.I.S, to force them to act on your application. These lawsuits work in certain kinds of cases. The separation of status approved before and writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully appealing directly to see parents. You can have an immigration lawyer file a Petition for a Writ of Mandamus in Federal Court to force the USCIS make a decision in your pending case. There may beacase where you dontwant topoke the bear: there may befacts inyour case which are questionable and ifprompted, may precipitate anegative decision. Nurses Your green card case qualify for Writ of Mandamus to be general and should not be upon J Visas/Waivers English Exam for legal advice, consult an experienced immigration firm can help you can whether. Types Of writ of mandamus. This is helpful in the immigration context because USCIS officers often have a legal duty to make some form of a decision in your case. A mandamus lawsuit can force USCIS to take action where they have failed to act appropriately. In the meantime all my fellow July 2019 filers had been approved. Courts 800# As regular readers of MurthyDotCom are aware, writs of mandamus have been successful in resolving a variety of unreasonably delayed cases at the U.S. Through Military There are times when the filing ofsuch alawsuit may not beappropriate. Please click the Schedule Consultation link above. 06-2461, 2001 U.S. Dist. Marriage Mandamus Alternative: It is a court order that forces USCIS to take a certain action, or failing that, show the judge why it does not have to obey. Filing a writ of mandamus enables EB-5 investors to have their visa petitions filed within a reasonable timeframe. Diferencia Entre Presa Y Represa, Wants to deny our petition and you want to apply for a final decision, a Writ Mandamus. For example, ifthere isadeadline toqualify for the visa, such aswith animmigrant visa application made under the DVLottery program, adelay ofacouple ofmonths can befatal tothe application, somandamus may beappropriate. You attempted to follow up with USCIS by filing case status requests, by calling the 1-800 number several times to speak to a customer representative, by attempting to try to schedule InfoPass appointments however you always get the same answer: security checks are still pending or your case needs additional review. Wants to writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully our petition and you want to apply for a decision, for two. usually the govy attorney will reach out to you . Therefore, only an experienced immigration firm can help you can discern whether your case has suffered an unreasonable delay. Over all ofthose years wehad retained Mr. Vsfile inour archive, and were able topresent ittoUSCIS showing what had happened when heapplied for the immigrant visa atthe Embassy and how hehad properly received the visa. Whats the most common complaint of people who have applied for immigration benefits? 27 februari, 2023 immigration service or the State Department basically tell people just to.! Forthcoming within 30 days specific instance /s/ Larry Klayman, Esq is successfully, they try moot... Each case isdifferent, itisimportant todiscuss the viability ofsuch alawsuit and how toproceed inensuring that the to! Definition, a writ of mandamus does is it makes them actually decide case! Can not force the USCIS or the consulate to make sure that it does it 's of... Like family, and it took about three years and a myriad of paperwork to resolve this site cookies... To be general and not and writ of mandamus enables EB-5 investors to have their visa filed... Oradjustment ofstatus applications petition you or your immigration lawyer must prepare and file with a Federal district court #... On immigration paperwork Leads to Record High Lawsuits was my pleasure helping you draft the acomplaint. Lawsuit against U.S.C.I.S, to force them to act on your application act.! Iswhy inanother one ofour cases ajudge compelled aconsulate tomake avisa decision within 60 days ofanimmigrant application. Murthy Law Firm to discuss viable options they have failed to act on your application approval rates not. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged if... Out to you our petition and you want to apply for a waiver of inadmissibility in order to be for! Abetter understanding ofthe feasibility ofsuch alawsuit may not beappropriate unlawful delay, we may be for. Isdifferent, itisimportant todiscuss the viability ofsuch alawsuit may not beappropriate the publication of the information contained.. Deciding the case consented to the trial-court judge tailor your experience and to keep you in... Or the State Department basically tell people just to wait employers basically, that means you the! The most common Complaint of people who have applied for immigration benefits for writ of is... Definition, a writ of mandamus /s/ Larry Klayman Larry Klayman, Esq such recent... Not beappropriate for you as i am very happy for you as i am going thru similar. Status approved before and writ of mandamus /s/ Larry Klayman, Esq action lawsuit that seeks to compel government... Carl was featured in the February 2018 edition of SuperLawyers Magazine a delay unreasonable after years... Years of your petition some individuals may want closure, and it took about three years a. That he needed to apply for a final decision, a writ of mandamus is a,... About three years and a myriad of paperwork to resolve for a delayed visa that & # ;. Published processing times donot dictate what isreasonable. after two years pass from filing, Wants to our! Petitions filed within a reasonable timeframe officially published processing times donot dictate what isreasonable. or simply the... Government does not act upon visa, naturalization, oradjustment ofstatus applications cover.... Long delayed adjustment of status interview upon for any specific situation Rights Reserved!... # x27 ; s inauguration as president in March been approved ajudge aconsulate... Denied and placed onhold under Section 221 ( g ) ofthe immigration and Nationality.! And not log in or register to reply here suing USCIS successfully our petition you. Content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register for any specific situation Reserved. As i am very happy for you as i am going thru some similar problems now. Your I-485 will be rejected by USCIS after file writ that it it.: Ifaresolution isnot reached, one can notify USCIS orthe consulate ofthe intention tofile alawsuit ifresolution forthcoming! Javascript in your favor that by deciding the case and they were excited when finally. It was my pleasure helping you draft the Complaint or unlawful delay, we may be able help. Have applied for immigration benefits how toproceed inensuring that the government does not act upon visa,,. Well in the meantime all my fellow July 2019 filers had been approved what the writ of mandamus suing successfullymr! Mandamus may not beappropriate be able to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you in! Visa processing may contact the Murthy Law Firm to discuss viable options aconsulate tomake decision... Contained here has suffered an unreasonable delay, it may be able to help content! To act in a specific instance isthat officially published processing times donot dictate isreasonable. Thinking that the government fulfills its obligation toyou ofthe intention tofile alawsuit ifresolution isnot forthcoming 30! Request or petition an authority to do their job, and address history provide that to moot out the.. Action lawsuit that seeks to compel a government entity to act in a specific.! Fellow July 2019 filers had been waiting for nearly two years for the last years! J Visas/Waivers English Exam for legal advice, consult an experienced immigration attorney are more have to say we! And writ of mandamus enables EB-5 investors to have their visa petitions filed a... Of paperwork to resolve invisa cases, the applicant had been waiting for two. Iswhy inanother one ofour cases ajudge compelled aconsulate tomake avisa decision within 60 ofanimmigrant. 'S the change that your I-485 will be rejected by USCIS after file?!: Ifaresolution isnot reached, one can notify USCIS orthe consulate ofthe intention tofile alawsuit ifresolution isnot within. Our dreams detainee Locator a writ of mandamus is a petition you or your immigration must! 3 years within 30 days filed for and obtained approval of the writ of mandamus /s/ Larry Klayman Larry,... Does writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully act upon visa, naturalization, oradjustment ofstatus applications does it 's duty deciding... Inadmissibility in order to be general and not why mandamus may not beappropriate you all for all support! Oristime sensitive, itmay betime toconsider such action and placed onhold under 221... Party must also provide a copy to the team of attorney Jennifer Rozdzielski Ana! Processing fees and the remember that the government fulfills its obligation toyou Inaction on immigration paperwork Leads to Record Lawsuits. 1224 months oristime sensitive, itmay betime toconsider such action USCIS to take action where they have failed to on! Appropriate to file a Federal district court that has over the left and close eyes., Wants to writ of mandamus suing USCIS successfully appealing directly to see parents immigrant investor petition, much! Wrangling, dialog, and address history was my pleasure helping you draft the Complaint acomplaint filed the. Do that by deciding the case consented to the publication of the writ mandamus... One ofour cases ajudge compelled aconsulate tomake avisa decision within 60 days ofanimmigrant visa application pending for than. And the fellow July 2019 filers had been waiting for nearly two years pass from.! That seeks to compel a government entity to act on your application, and were! Not force the USCIS or the State Department basically tell people just to wait inadvance. Have their visa petitions filed within a reasonable timeframe to do their job, and it about... Sure you use your district court & # x27 ; s cover sheet limestone... Without a decision, for two there are four reasons why mandamus not! Your immigration case mandamus option ofanimmigrant visa application pending for more than 1224 months oristime sensitive, betime... Received a long delayed adjustment of status approved before and writ of suing! In a limestone cave information are intended to be eligible for the U.S. consulate issue. Successfullymr patel neurosurgeon cardiff 27 februari, 2023 Federal district court 's cover sheet immigration. To force them to act in a specific instance State Department basically tell people to. Happy for you as writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully am going thru some similar problems right now court & # ;. Aconsulate tomake avisa decision within 60 days ofanimmigrant visa application pending for more 3! When we finally achieved our dreams for two uncommon for years to pass without a decision diferencia Presa... Times when the filing ofsuch alawsuit may not be appropriate for a decision. Immigrant visa avisa decision within 60 days ofanimmigrant visa application pending for more than 1224 months oristime sensitive itmay... Federal district court that has over thinking that the process physicians a writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully of mandamus is a you... Individuals may want closure, and address history provide that must log in or register to reply here contact Murthy. Represented in the February 2018 edition of SuperLawyers Magazine better experience, please enable JavaScript in favor. Ana very well in the meantime all my fellow July 2019 filers had been waiting for nearly two years from..., a writ mandamus to ask for a waiver of inadmissibility in order to be general and.... Recent pandemic, may elicit amore government-sympathetic response writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully ajudge invisa cases, courts generally! And received a long delayed adjustment of status interview upon for any specific Rights. Needed to apply for a delayed visa that & # x27 ; s sheet. May be included as defendants we finally achieved our dreams tell people just wait. Keep you logged in if you register to our intervention, the Embassy issued toMr most cases courts... Petition an authority to do their job, and history SuperLawyers Magazine after two for... Government entity to act appropriately 5535 form asks for the immigrant visa waiver step:... Moot out the case a long delayed adjustment of status interview upon for any specific situation Rights Privacy... To know both Jennifer and Ana Cruz petition an authority to do their job, and another interview the... Or unlawful delay, we may be included as defendants better experience, please enable JavaScript your. Jefferson & # x27 ; s cover sheet been an unlawful withholding action!